Closure of Marks and Spencer would leave a big hole in town

Trusted article source icon
Friday, July 23, 2010
Profile image for This is Scunthorpe

This is Scunthorpe

SHOPPERS and businesses in Scunthorpe reacted with shock after Marks & Spencer announced plans to close the High Street store.

The retail giant, which has had a presence on Scunthorpe High Street since 1932, plans to close the store in early 2011 with the loss of 36 jobs.

Scunthorpe MP Nic Dakin said he was stunned by the news.

"It's very disappointing. It seems to have come out of the blue as the shop has always appeared very busy and popular," he told the Telegraph.

"It's hard to understand why it's not doing well."

Scunthorpe town centre businessman and managing director of Fallen Hero, Des Comerford, said: "For Marks & Spencer to say sales have declined over the past three years, I think it is clear to see that they, in my opinion, have not invested in the town centre over a long period of time.

"My heart goes out to the people who work there and have been committed to that store for a long time."

Mr Comerford praised North Lincolnshire Council for its intended attempts to keep Marks and Spencer in the town – but was unsure what the authority could do.

He said: "I welcome Councillor Mark Kirk's comments as leader of North Lincolnshire Council that they will sit down and try to do everything they can.

"I will be interested to see what ideas these are because there is no manoeuvre with the business rates or rent and I can't see where the help could come from or what sort of help can come from the council."

And he said the retailers in the town centre should be given a greater voice in a bid to arrest the decline of the area.

Mr Comerford said: "We need a think tank very quickly to stop any further decline in the town centre.

"Let's all sit around the table and pull together for the sake of North Lincolnshire.

"We have got to listen to the retailers and businesses in the town centre because they know what is happening on a day-to-day basis."

Glyn Sparks, manager of town centre store Inter Sport, said: "To lose such a traditional shop from Scunthorpe is shocking.

"We've got plenty of new, cheap shops in Scunthorpe but we're losing the traditional ones.

"As a businessman, yes, the news is deeply concerning because you cannot help but think, who's next?"

Andy Nash, manager at John's Audio & Visual Specialists, was also surprised at the news.

"I'm speechless to be honest," he said.

"The closure of Marks & Spencer will dramatically cut down on foot traffic through the High Street as it is one of the town's busiest shops. The reduction of people will obviously have an effect on the amount of shoppers in town centre. We are already seeing the Doncaster Road end of the High Street become quieter but we could see the Westgate end become equally as deserted."

He added: "I think most shops are going to end up in retail parks like Lakeside and Gallaher Retail Park and people will tend to go to places like Meadowhall to shop."

And Paul Empson, owner of Paul's Music on Laneham Street, said: "The closure of Marks & Spencer is going to leave big hole in the High Street.

"If shops like this keep closing there'll be nothing left.

"As a local businessman I support all local businesses so, yes, the closure of Scunthorpe's Marks & Spencer is deeply upsetting."

It is a sad turn of events for the Scunthorpe store, the High Street's oldest retailer. Just 12 years ago, the board of directors pledged a full commitment to the future of the town.

On December 21, 1998 Marks & Spencer announced plans to build a new 36,000 square feet store – more than four times the size of the present branch.

The site earmarked was that of the former John Leggott College in nearby Cole Street, which has since been demolished to make way for the Parishes shopping mall.

At the time, a spokeswoman for Marks & Spencer said the relocation of the store would provide a much greater choice for customers.

She said: "The company is fully committed to being part of the future of Scunthorpe."

The council's then development chairman Councillor Mark Kirk, now the leader of the local authority, welcomed the commitment, hailing it as a massive boost to the town centre and putting Scunthorpe in a position to compete with neighbouring town high streets.

The commitment to the future of Scunthorpe came after the company abandoned plans to build a £21-million superstore on the Hull side of the Humber Bridge amid a storm of protest from local traders.

Despite the doom and gloom surrounding the proposed closure, speaking yesterday Mr Kirk said there is plenty of investment heading to the region.

He said: "We are seeing more people coming into the town and with Primark moving in the autumn, this will bring even more people.

"Together with the Lincolnshire Lakes project and the recent announcement on the South Humber Gateway that will attract thousands of new jobs to the area, there are promising times ahead.

"And we are currently talking to potential new developers about the prospect of them coming to the town – this is part of the town centre master plan that will again see more jobs created in the town centre through a series of major key development opportunities."

9
Tweet this article
Report

9 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Scunthorpe

    by RobS, Goole

    Monday, July 26 2010, 7:02PM

    “'Cheapened and destroyed'? Get a life for goodness sake ! Who cares that M&S have a store in town or not? Who actually shops there? The stores have been over priced and nothing special for years. What all town centres need are exciting new shops from small business owners who should be encouraged with low rates and special deals. Shops open and close all the time and personally, I find the pound shops and clearance stores far more exciting than the large chain stores selling the same stuff at twice the price.
    Fine the owners of premises for empty property and they will soon find short-term tenants who want to try a business venture and rents will come down for short leases.”

  • Profile image for This is Scunthorpe

    by Disillusioned with North Lincs, Forging its Future & Image?!

    Saturday, July 24 2010, 3:42PM

    “Steven, Even if they were listening, these has beens and never weres haven't the intellect or calibre to change.

    If only I could take full advantage of Scunthorpe's and Nth Lincs' 2 most redeeming attributes, M181S and M180W!!

    Just need the ST to keep forging the constant hype from the local movers and shakers that Nth Lincs is a fantastic place to live, work and do business! And from DDM that local property is so damn cheap and plenty available! And thereby you have to wonder why, such a contradiction in terms?!!”

  • Profile image for This is Scunthorpe

    by ad, n lincs

    Saturday, July 24 2010, 8:46AM

    “alleged???”

  • Profile image for This is Scunthorpe

    by On the Side Line, Scunthorpe

    Saturday, July 24 2010, 7:56AM

    “I am disgusted by the alleged closure of M&S and I don't think the council have helped the town centre one bit. The town is full of cheap crappy shops (there are a few exceptions) but why do people keep moaning about the development of the The Pods, I think it is a good thing for the town, the lesiure centre is disgusting and in my opinion should have been knocked down years ago. I am looking forward to the opening of the the Pods and will be an avid user of the facilities.”

  • Profile image for This is Scunthorpe

    by steven, scunny

    Friday, July 23 2010, 3:06PM

    “Disolutioned ,don't hold back tell them what you really feel. If they don't listen theres always the road out.”

  • Profile image for This is Scunthorpe

    by DavidBrent, Ghost Town, Central Scunthorpe

    Friday, July 23 2010, 11:20AM

    “Thinking about the headline, shouldn't it be "Closure of M & S leaves a big town in a hole"?

    Oh well i suppose cash converters could always expand into there or booze master perhaps?”

  • Profile image for This is Scunthorpe

    by kno it all, barton-upon-humber

    Friday, July 23 2010, 10:48AM

    “In 1998 who was in charge of development and was useless,and who is in complete charge now and still completely useless why no other than CAPTAIN KIRK.Him and his administration have and will continue to ruin Scunthorpe by spending taxpayers money on ridiculous projects.Not for the good of North Lincs but to make him look good!”

  • Profile image for This is Scunthorpe

    by Disillusioned with North Lincs, Forging its Future & Image?!

    Friday, July 23 2010, 10:14AM

    “As a relative newcomer, having taken note of the dire track record, conduct and performance of your 3rd rate politicians and councillors here in North Lincolnshire; it should be no surprise that your 2nd rate councils have achieved very little in their part to halt the demise of Scunthorpe town centre and other areas of Nth Lincs economy, image and reputation.

    What the local political, legal and supposed democratic systems lack in quality, substance, calibre and integrity to serve and meet the wider public interests; they make up for by being arrogant, devious and deceitful in protecting and defending their own personal and political interests and their "system" at all costs.

    And given the political toing and froing, infighting and failures of successive councils to do their bit in supporting, managing and maintaining a viable and successful Scunthorpe centre, Market areas and entertainment venues. How can anyone possibly have any confidence and trust in their judgments and decisions to throw £41 million of public money at the Pods and Baths or their alleged new found ability to manage viable and successful developments?!

    When the local High Street and economy has clearly been brought to its knees through mismanagement; surely the writing is on the wall for the potential for council tax payers (in already the country's 4th highest taxing local authority) to once again be left with picking up a substantial tab for this council's ill thought out excesses?!”

  • Profile image for This is Scunthorpe

    by David Brent, Ghost town central Scunthorpe

    Friday, July 23 2010, 9:54AM

    “As the retailers rightly have said another nail in the coffin for Scunthorpe town centre, surely this can't be allowed to continue. M & S is just another extension of the continued bleed away from our centre to the periphary of town and the retail parks. B & M, Poundland, Greggs, Savers, Sportsdirect, cash converters, pawnbrokers r us and the money shop are indicative of how our town has become cheapened and destroyed. Where is the investment? Where is the new market? Where is the re-development? Apart from the new 'Primark' (Deary me...) what hope has the town centre got?

    Nothing.

    When one the premium Parishes stores continues to sit empty (the old Walmart) the closed sign may as well extend to the whole town centre a flagship retail building with no one in it is an embarassment and a scandal.

    Show us the plans to keep our town centre alive council!”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article