Doncaster Road M&S retail park plan approved again by councillors

Trusted article source icon
Wednesday, March 07, 2012
Profile image for This is Scunthorpe

This is Scunthorpe

The way is now clear for Marks & Spencer to establish a new store on the outskirts of Scunthorpe.

North Lincolnshire Council’s planning committee – meeting at Scunthorpe Civic Centre, Ashby Road, this afternoon – decided to grant planning permission for Simons Developments Ltd's out-of-town retail park project earmarked for land in Doncaster Road, Gunness.

  1. Artist's impression of the proposed retail park which is set to be built on Doncaster Road on the outskirts of Scunthorpe. The development could bring Marks & Spencer back to the area.

    Artist's impression of the proposed retail park which is set to be built on Doncaster Road on the outskirts of Scunthorpe. The development could bring Marks & Spencer back to the area.

  2. North Lincolnshire Council planning committee chairman Arthur Bunyan who cast the deciding vote

    North Lincolnshire Council planning committee chairman Arthur Bunyan who cast the deciding vote

The verdict was passed on the casting vote of chairman Arthur Bunyan, following a 5-5 split vote from councillors.

Councillors originally voted in favour of granting permission in December but were asked to reconsider the plans after the Keep Scunthorpe Alive campaign group took the first steps towards a legal challenge.

BLINDS & CURTAINS MADE 2 MEASURE WE COVER SCUNTHORPE & GRIMSBY...

Grimsby Sunblinds

View details

Print voucher

FREE MEASURING AND FITTING SERVICE** Phone 809887 for a free home visit www.grimsby-sunblinds.co.uk

Contact: 01472 809887

Valid until: Friday, May 31 2013

The group pressed for the proposal to be rejected because of its potential to cause a devastating effect on the town centre.

The application approved is to demolish Trent Valley Garden Centre in Gunness, and its associated structures (including three residential properties) and erect a retail park with associated access roads, car parking, servicing areas and hard and soft landscaping.

Addressing the latest meeting, Tony Coe, owner of High Street-based Coe & Co jewellers, said: “It is clear to see that the number of out-of-town retail parks that have been approved in this area has had a severe negative impact on the retail environment within Scunthorpe town centre.

“If this proposed development is allowed to go ahead, it would be nothing short of catastrophic and would indeed be the death knell of our High Street.”

Councillors were shown plans drawn up on behalf of Keep Scunthorpe Alive which demonstrate how a similar project could be accommodated in the town centre.

Ian McPherson, a resident of the Lodge Moor estate near the application site, said: “The new plans that Keep Scunthorpe Alive has produced eradicate all of the issues and it is a less disruptive and more beneficial development.

“We as a town have an opportunity to get what we all want. We want M&S back in town but in the town centre, where shops truly belong.”

Speaking in favour of the scheme, Simons group development director Chris Newsome looked to ease concerns about the future of the town centre.

He said: “This will only comprise four units and a legal agreement prevents town centre retailers from taking those units.

“The town centre will not be moving to Doncaster Road.”

Opponents vow to fight on after retail park approved again

0
Tweet this article
Report

Comments

  • Profile image for free_britain

    by free_britain

    Tuesday, March 13 2012, 2:20PM

    “by gludiog

    I read these type of threads all the time on here and I wonder why so many people in Scunthorpe really want to see the demise of the town centre.
    ........................................................

    The problem in Scunthorpe is that by and large, it is a left-wing town and as such, everybody has this belief that they "are owed something" and that everybody in every town across the country actually gets what they're owed, and they don't.

    Then, on the other hand there are those that are more conservative that perish the thought of actually stepping foot in to a town as "Ghastly" as Scunthorpe and cringe at the thought of actually being able to get what they want here as this would blow away all their preconceived ideal's about how down trodden and unworthy their own town actually is.

    "Victim's" mentality I think it's called.

    I know several people that live in Sheffield and they'd rather shove hot coals up their backside than go to Meadow Hall, whereas the "victims" in the satellite towns believe that it's the bee knees.”

  • Profile image for gludiog

    by gludiog

    Tuesday, March 13 2012, 12:52PM

    “'' Its just evolution you can't stop it but you can try and stand in the way and let it sink you."

    .. and soon we will end up with no legs as we do away with the need to use them.

    But on a serious note. I read these type of threads all the time on here and I wonder why so many people in Scunthorpe really want to see the demise of the town centre. I rarely shop in Scunthorpe to be honest, convenience dictates that I go to Grimsby or sometimes Lincoln, or even the other side of the water, but what I see in each of these places is out of town developments but also a thriving or semi thriving town centre .. why cant the two work hand in hand? Why have the people of Scunthorpe and NLC decided that they are going to lead some sort of headlong charge to change the layout of Scunthorpe and obliterate the town centre?”

  • Profile image for free_britain

    by free_britain

    Monday, March 12 2012, 11:53PM

    “by Angrier

    to the destination shops of Tesco B&Q Next and Toys R Us is survive. By putting all the best shops together
    ....................................
    And you say that only the brainless, low life and drunks go into town!

    Personally speaking, I can't remember the last time that my weekends shopping was spent perusing tins of paint, wooden shelving systems, doors frames and kids dummies and rattles all whilst avoiding half-wits in the car park that have road rage from spending 30 minutes being trapped in the exit lane.

    You crack on pal, at least it'll keep all the "tyre kickers" and those that are on family day trips to the destinations stores like Tesco and B&Q away from the town!!”

  • Profile image for localad

    by localad

    Monday, March 12 2012, 10:04PM

    “Bang on Tfi, plus your letter was quite amusing, made me smile.”

  • Profile image for Angrier

    by Angrier

    Monday, March 12 2012, 7:48PM

    “I hate to say it, but as I warned last week it looks as though its "game over" at Game and Gamestation on the High Street.
    Their share price fell another 70% today as the directors have said that failure to secure supply of new stock meant that the company may be effectively worthless to current shareholders.
    That makes it highly likely to go into administration or even insolvency.
    If it's administration then a buyer will be sought for the shops which may result in some surviving - I would have put it highly unlikely that 2 shops from the same group would survive within metres of each other.

    Either way its another failed retailer and more empty shops likely in High Streets all over the country.
    Why?
    The stock market is blaming its shops as being too expensive to run when competeing with internet only sales.
    The market evolved but Game didn't do it quickly enough and has been left behind.

    So M&S near Tesco not to blame.
    Neither were they to blame for Woolworths, Peacocks, Bon Marche, Internationale, La Senza etc etc........

    What M&S clearly are trying to do by moving close to the destination shops of Tesco B&Q Next and Toys R Us is survive. By putting all the best shops together in one easily accessible place, with car parking you may encourage some cross selling. That may protect jobs and create new.

    Teh writing as on the wall for Scunthorpe when Binns left - flagship store had now use for Scunny High Street , so all those complaning should get real and be thankfull there may be jobs on Doncaster Road.

    After all who decided that Scunthorpe should have the jobs on the High Street, not Ashby etc? Its just evolution you can't stop it but you can try and stand in the way and let it sink you.”

  • Profile image for PStoff

    by PStoff

    Monday, March 12 2012, 7:39PM

    “Terrible spelling belies your IQ. Also turn your caps lock off. You're saying nothing so why try and shout it?”

  • Profile image for bastard57

    by bastard57

    Monday, March 12 2012, 6:18PM

    “AS ALWAYS THE PLANNERS THINK THEY NO BEST /ALL THIS WILL DO IS CAUSE TRAFFIC CAOUS AND WILL DRIVE SHOPPERS AWAY FROM THIS RETAIL PARK NOT TO IT
    I WONDER WHAT HAIR BRAIN SCHEME THE HIGHWAYS WILL COME UP WITH TO COMPONSATE FOR THE EXTRA TRAFFIC AND WHAT ABOUT THE LORRYS ETC DURING DEMOLISION AND BUILDIN THE NEW SHOPS
    REGARDS CCTVJOHN”

  • Profile image for Frogsquasher

    by Frogsquasher

    Monday, March 12 2012, 5:25PM

    “Anyone who supports our 'state of the art(LESS)' High St is obviously mentally retarded and should be shown pity not be ridiculed.”

  • Profile image for PStoff

    by PStoff

    Monday, March 12 2012, 4:47PM

    “Bang on TFI.”

  • Profile image for CelticFCgirl

    by CelticFCgirl

    Monday, March 12 2012, 4:24PM

    “TFI you are absolutely bang on, our high street is an ugly eyesore that to all intents and purposes looks like it has been bombed and badly patched together again!

    The high street seems to be largely aimed at the very hard up - cheap household stuff, bargain booze, a shop to pawn the kid's playstation when you need money to pay the tally man, a shop to get about £3000 finance on nice new flat screen tv - it's ok you only have to pay £5 a week for the rest of your life!At that price why not get another £4000 finance on a nice new pvc sofa to put in front of it. It's ridculous and undeniable that the high street is unpleasant, tatty and full of chavs and drunks that I have found intimidating at times!”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Be the first to comment

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article